Log in

it's going to be legendary!
R1C3 - Voting 
29th-Aug-2009 10:38 pm

chemicalbullet - failure to enter with no byes remaining

Please be kind when giving "reasons", think constructive, try not list personal reasons or preferences (ie - "I don't like the color blue", a better response would be "there's too much blue in the icon" or "another color may have suited the original image better").


1 2 3
4 5 6
7 8 9

* please note the corresponding numbers are above each icon.

Voting will close Monday at 12pm (PST)
{ doctor } tardis
30th-Aug-2009 05:05 am (UTC)
Voting Off:
LEAST FAVORITE (-2 points): #01 - The icon is very sharp, esp. on their edges, like a rough cut out.
SECOND-LEAST FAVORITE (-1 points): #04 - The crop doesn't really work with this cap, there's nothing interesting to focus on, the icon is also a bit oversaturated, shows on his hands.

FAVORITE (+2 points): #07 - lovely soft blending of the background
SECOND-FAVORITE (+1 points): #08 - great use of text texture
30th-Aug-2009 11:33 am (UTC)
Voting Off:
LEAST FAVORITE (-2 points): #01 - the smaller image on top of the larger one doesn't compliment the icon well as the different colourings don't blend well and the smaller image is too sharp.
SECOND-LEAST FAVORITE (-1 points): #02 - the icon is a bit too sharp around the edges, showing its been imposed on the new background.

FAVORITE (+2 points): #08 - great colouring and text.
SECOND-FAVORITE (+1 points): #06.
30th-Aug-2009 12:12 pm (UTC)
Voting Off:
LEAST FAVORITE (-2 points): #01 - The cropping and merging is a bit irritating to look at and the colouring is unfitting.
SECOND-LEAST FAVORITE (-1 points): #04 - It looks blurry and too much of the body takes up the icon and makes it seem stuffed.

FAVORITE (+2 points): #08 - Cropping = GREAT! font used = perfect and all in all it makes for an entertaining icon. great.
SECOND-FAVORITE (+1 points): #07 - the difference between the blurry background and the sharp characters is exactly right, as is the colouring. Also the hint of texture fits well and makes the icon more interesting the eye.
(Deleted comment)
30th-Aug-2009 09:58 pm (UTC)
You forgot to note the number for the second icon under voting off :).
30th-Aug-2009 02:51 pm (UTC)
Voting Off:
LEAST FAVORITE (-2 points): #01 - Contrast too high, too sharp. At first, didn't recognize the bigger picture in the back, now I find Barney's face in the background too distracting.
SECOND-LEAST FAVORITE (-1 points): #05 - Too dark, text is hardly distiguishable from background.

FAVORITE (+2 points): #08 - Like the cropping, nice contrast and color. Great text placement.
SECOND-FAVORITE (+1 points): #07. - Nice masking and sublte use of texture. I really like the light coming from the bottom.
30th-Aug-2009 05:18 pm (UTC)
Voting Off:
LEAST FAVORITE (-2 points): #01 - Poor composition. Feels like they were cut and pasted into a bigger bed. Also a little sharp as well, around Robin's hair.
SECOND-LEAST FAVORITE (-1 points): #09 - The icon and text is a little blurry, could use some sharpening.

FAVORITE (+2 points): #02 - Nice use of text and backgound color.
SECOND-FAVORITE (+1 points): #04 - Nice crop.
1st-Sep-2009 04:23 am (UTC)
This page was loaded Feb 21st 2017, 2:16 pm GMT.