Log in

it's going to be legendary!
R1C2 - Voting 
15th-Aug-2009 02:35 am

Please be kind when giving "reasons", think constructive, try not list personal reasons or preferences (ie - "I don't like the color blue", a better response would be "there's too much blue in the icon" or "another color may have suited the original image better").


1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8
9 10

* please note the corresponding numbers are above each icon.

&& If you've got the time voting is also up for my other LIMS comm, psychusa_lims.
{ doctor } tardis
15th-Aug-2009 10:29 am (UTC)
Voting Off:
LEAST FAVORITE (-2 points): #02 - Texture(?) makes the icon look too grainy, hardly any contrast.
SECOND-LEAST FAVORITE (-1 points): #03 - Texture too overwhelming, makes Robin too yellow/orange-y and masks too many details.

FAVORITE (+2 points): #07 - Nice cropping and use of textures. Text fits well and doesn't distract too much from the pic.
SECOND-FAVORITE (+1 points): #06. Original use of texture, like the combination with b&w.
15th-Aug-2009 02:35 pm (UTC)
Voting Off:
LEAST FAVORITE (-2 points): #09 - She is too blurry, could use some sharpening.
SECOND-LEAST FAVORITE (-1 points): #03 - The texture used makes her too orange/yellow.

FAVORITE (+2 points): #04 - Nice crop, contrast and the text is hilarious and well placed.
SECOND-FAVORITE (+1 points): #01- Nice color for such a dark picture to begin with.
15th-Aug-2009 03:30 pm (UTC)
Voting Off:
LEAST FAVORITE (-2 points): #03 - The coloring is too yellow/orange, and Robin needs sharpening, so she stands out more clearly from the background.
SECOND-LEAST FAVORITE (-1 points): #02 - The image is too dull and needs to be brightened up, so you can see Ted and Marshall's expressions more clearly.

FAVORITE (+2 points): #04 - Great placement of image in the lower corner! Also, good contrast in the faces, so you can see their expressions clearly. Funnt text, too.
SECOND-FAVORITE (+1 points): #05 -- Lovely, soft coloring and interesting text placement over the hands. Nice choice of text, too.
15th-Aug-2009 10:02 pm (UTC)
Voting Off:
LEAST FAVORITE (-2 points): #02 - they're a bit too dark, and the red noise texture (?) doesn't fit
SECOND-LEAST FAVORITE (-1 points): #08 - the blue stripe is too bold and thus distracting

FAVORITE (+2 points): #10 - love the coloring
SECOND-FAVORITE (+1 points): #01.

also, I just sent you an invite to lims_voters - in case you need more votes, you can post the links there; you only have to vote in 1 or 2 other comms in return ;)
15th-Aug-2009 10:11 pm (UTC)
Voting Off:
LEAST FAVORITE (-2 points): #10 - I think the colouring is too dull and the cropping off the top bit is weirdly uneven.
SECOND-LEAST FAVORITE (-1 points): #2 - Icon is too dark.

FAVORITE (+2 points): #6 - I think it's an interesting composition.
SECOND-FAVORITE (+1 points): #5 - I like the effect of the text and lighting together
16th-Aug-2009 05:18 pm (UTC)
Voting Off:
LEAST FAVORITE (-2 points): #09 - the icon is too blurry.
SECOND-LEAST FAVORITE (-1 points): #03 - the texture is too overpowering.

FAVORITE (+2 points): #06 - gorgeous composition.
SECOND-FAVORITE (+1 points): #10.
17th-Aug-2009 04:22 am (UTC)
Voting Off:
LEAST FAVORITE (-2 points): #10 - not enough contrast, awkward cropping and use of text
SECOND-LEAST FAVORITE (-1 points): #02 - strange red & blue texture or brush hurts the icon

FAVORITE (+2 points): #04 - great cropping and use of text
SECOND-FAVORITE (+1 points): #07 - nice coloring on a difficult cap and good use of text and textures
18th-Aug-2009 02:37 pm (UTC) - yeah, I can still vote!
Voting Off:
LEAST FAVORITE (-2 points): #10 - The icon is too blurry for my taste, there's been no work done on the overall colours and the text does not fit well.
SECOND-LEAST FAVORITE (-1 points): #09 - There should be more contrast and the text looks like it's been squeezed in.

FAVORITE (+2 points): #04 - The cropping is brilliant and the text fits perfectly (placement, font and meaning).
SECOND-FAVORITE (+1 points): #07 - Once again, great cropping and I really like the textures used as they underline the icon brilliantly and make it more interesting to look at.
22nd-Aug-2009 02:27 am (UTC)
This page was loaded Feb 21st 2017, 2:16 pm GMT.